“A gunman invaded an immigration services center…” So begins the lede sentence to the New York Times story about the massacre in Binghamton, N.Y. at the hands of Jiverly Wong.
For most of Friday, officials kept Wong’s identity a closely held secret until it was leaked. But why the reluctance to fully reveal these facts: Jiverly Wong, 42, an Asian American immigrant, opened fire on a citizenship class in Binghamton, N.Y., shooting 13 people and wounding 4 others before taking his own life.
What were officials afraid of? Whipping up some ethnic stereotype? (Crazy murderous Asians, anyone?) Or creating a backlash against Asians and Asian Americans? Whites didn’t fear a backlash when a John Wayne Gacy or a Jeffrey Dahmer appeared, why should Asians now?
In this sad tale, race and ethnicity are what makes this story. It’s not a generic mainstream thing. The Wong rampage is about the violence that can stem from the very real and specific cultural schizophrenia that results from the psycho journey that is immigration.
In a country of new immigrants, we need to do more than check for green cards and passports. We need to check with people’s mental health.
Wong was just another Asian American immigrant lost in language and communication, culture and society, and it all contributed to what we saw on Friday.
There are a lot of Wongs in America. And they need help, before it’s too late.
We just don’t hear about them much because, of course, mental illness is so stigmatized in the Asian American community, that not even the drugs to remedy it can make it seem cool or attractive. Culturally, Asian Americans prefer to deal with these issues quietly, away from mental health arena. Besides what are the chances of finding someone trained in language, or with the cultural awareness to recognize and deal with the most troubled situations? Not so good. In normal medical situations, finding doctors and nurses who can communicate with immigrant patients with normal needs is hard enough.
What do we know of Wong? That he lived in Inglewood, Calif from 2000-2007, according to the Times story. That he worked as a delivery driver for a sushi company. A Vietnamese doing sushi deliveries. Seen one Asian, seen them all.
Paulus Lukas, the H.R. person for the sushi company told a reporter Wong had few friends and wasn’t social. “I cannot point to anybody here who really knew him because he was not outgoing,” Lukas said in a report. Or maybe Wong just felt trapped in his own immigrant’s hell. I wonder if his medical records show he sought any help or counseling? Or if as his co-workers observed, he was merely seen as a quiet person who kept to himself. Nothing unusual. In fact for an Asian American, that sounds “normal.”
In the case of Seung-Hui Cho, the Virginia Tech shooter and the perpetrator of the biggest shooting spree in modern American history, his parents didn’t know what to do with all the signs they were getting.
They turned to a minister.
That didn’t work.
Part of the problem goes to the identity of the perpetrators. In both Wong and Cho, were two men in need of addressing a certain mental anguish that comes with being an Asian American, caught in a void between cultures. When those like Wong and Cho have trouble identifying themselves in this new society, that’s when trouble begins.
In the end, both men chose to go out American-style, violently, guns ablazing, perhaps the only part of our modern culture to which they could truly and deeply relate.
Both incidents show that diversity sprouts new and unique problems in every arena. Now the two biggest shootings in recent American history are at the hands of Asian Americans. That should be an alarm to those APAs in public health, especially in the mental health area. There should also be a concern to community folks and activists who may have sorely neglected the need to talk about such things as violence in general, domestic violence, and specifically, guns.
Guns as the answer? Not in the old country. Only in the New America.
dear Emil,
please don’t jump on conclusion first because of news and medias. no one knows which news is the right one yet .you know about tv and news in the U S.They never favor to any minorities group except for mostly white and their interest. don’t you see how come san francisco chronical news changing tone and subject since last night, even we don’t give a danm about them. the point is, Voong’ve been living in US 28 years and couldn’t speak English?Funny TV news. what’s behind all that? and also , that small town is about 80% are white and we know all about between old white immigrants and new commers don’t we? we can’t compare Voong and Cho because according form news, Voong is IBM employee engineer and sushi delivery man?mmmm?Cho is sharp shooter and Virginia Tech student, but they both have one thing in comman, that is discrimination. i have to agree with you that ,whites didn’t fear a backlash when john wayne ,Gacy or jeffery appreared and kill all kinds of native indian brothers and sisthers? yes, we all know asian love peace and justice.
r n
–nai reig on Apr 04, 2009
Just want to clarify that neither Wong or Voong are Vietnamese names. Vietnamese ethnic names do not have a W, as there is no letter W in the Vietnamese alphabet. If there was a French person who may have departed Vietnam as their last country before arriving in the U.S., I don’t think they would be called ethnically Vietnamese. It is indeed a very sad tragedy for the victims, but we need to make sure we get the facts right. Citizenship and ethnicity are two distinct elements.
–maithu on Apr 05, 2009
Maithu, why does it matter if the person has a Vietnamese last name or not? I think he was ethnic Chinese from Vietnam – doesn’t that make his national origin Vietnamese?
In the end, why does it matter? The man had mental health problems – a problem that is not addressed in either community, whether Chinese American or Vietnamese American. Better stated, mental health is a problem that most Asian Americans and immigrants have problems addressing and I think it’s anti-productive to create unnecessary ethnic divisions.
Hi Emil, you know, this story also gets me thinking of the relatively recent news of the Chinese Canadian who knifed, beheaded, and cannibalized a young man on the Greyhound bus. Apparently there were serious mental health issues and issues of social alienation as well, and maybe we don’t hear much about this story and the trial in our news because it’s Canadian?
It’s tough enough to deal with all Asian American pathologies. But Canadians too? Of course, I’m only partly joking. News is becoming so localized these days even as life becomes more global, it’s funny how Asian Canadian stories just don’t get much play here. It’s too bad. We should hope that the mental health professionals at the very least following these examples in real time, because by time it hits the research books, it’s often too late.
Please share the links here. There are many Asian Americans with relatives in B.C., and throughout Canada. Because of lighter immigration restrictions, more from the homeland go there and not to the U.S.
For many the difference between being A.C. or A.A. is a quota list at some bureaucracy.