It felt like the night George Bush won and Al Gore lost.
This was a night when meritocracy in pop America really lost.
It’s still not as bad as if William Hung had won. It’s not as big a fraud as say calling the Monkees better than the Beatles.
But everyone knows Adam Lambert should have been declared this year’s “American Idol” winner.
Lambert’s talent just dwarfed all the others. Adam made Kris look like Opie at the junior high talent show.
At first, the night had appeared somewhat stacked in Adam’s favor. On this final episode, he got to sing with no less than Kiss and Queen, essentially a grand showcase of the eye-linered contestant with his musical forebears. It almost seemed a pre-annointing of the winner.
So when Kris was announced as the “Idol” it just seemed like a false note.
But what do you expect from a multiple-vote system. It’s been said America doesn’t like to sense its vote doesn’t count. The AI system indulges those voters. Vote doesn’t count? Make it count 10 times. Vote all you want. It’s an all-you-can-eat democracy. But it does make the vote about the voters and not about the talent on stage.
Doesn’t matter. Before long, Kris will be joining previous winner Taylor Hicks on the county fair circuit.
Meanwhile, Adam will emerge quite simply as the most versatile and gifted performer birthed by the show ever.
Talent always wins out in the end.
I highly disagree with your assertion that Adam Lambert was head and shoulders above Kris in terms of talent. I haven’t talked to an actual musician that thinks that. Kris possesses TONS of talent and his voice is much more enjoyable to listen to…not to mention he plays like 4-5 instruments (very well, I might add). Yes, Adam has a great voice and possesses a lot of talent but he’s a one trick pony. He sings high and loudly…he can’t sing as well on softer songs. Just because he sings loud and high doesn’t mean he’s more talented. In fact, most vocalist have a hard time singing lower with a good tone and Kris can do that. I think Kris and Adam were both deserving enough to win and I think America got it right. Kris will not join the county fair circuit as you put it…he’s got way more pure talent than Adam. Just listen to “Heartless” and tell me he didn’t do better than Adam. Adam couldn’t have done that song. If he did he would just scream loudly.
Different kind of singers. Different kinds of talents. Adam’s fills the room in a flash and hits you like a sledgehammer. Kris’s quieter talent is a lot more subtle, and envelopes you like smoke. There’s a place for both, but in my opinion, Adam’s overwhelming and consistent style throughout the season was far more deserving.